Sunday, June 20, 2010

RED ALERT :How to tackle the Maoist menace...

The defining image of the week is of a victorious West Bengal police officer carrying a bamboo pole, the corpse of a slain Naxalite tied to it, his face exultant, his body language (appallingly) euphoric. To quote the Times of India, “The Centre rightly criticises the way the bodies were borne. Suggesting lack of respect for the dead, the images aren’t good PR.”
This unspeakably barbaric, insensitive act, apart from bringing a bad name to security personnel, also indicates a failure of the imagination: is this the way we are going to fight the (in the Prime Minister’s words) “gravest internal security threat” facing the country? It seems as if security personnel are whipping themselves up to a frenzy of ‘korbo, lorbo, jitbo re’ (We’ll do it, we’ll fight it out, we’ll win!), a credo which is every bit as ineffectual as in the IPL for the hopeless Knight Riders. Even the army is---unfortunately--- following suit. It is reportedly drawing up plans to raise five divisions, or 50,000 soldiers, of crack anti-Naxalite commandos.
They are losing the bigger picture...Sorry; WE are losing the bigger picture. The fight against the Maoist menace is an exercise in tightrope walking, not an out-and-out conventional war. We are trying to redress a long history of torture. We seek to bring disillusioned tribals into democracy’s fold. And the path, ladies and gentlemen, is NOT a straight one.
The Naxalite problem is basically the result of terrible misgovernance in tribal areas. Corrupt officials/policemen/politicians (take your pick), unscrupulous forest contractors/land-grabbers (take your pick again!) and illegal mining have forced young tribals to take to arms out of sheer desperation. And to think, we expect to reverse all this through mere force... As in the northeast, as in Jammu & Kashmir, the deployment of the military can only aggravate the problem, creating a perception of the Indian state at war with its own people. This, interestingly, is PRECISELY what the rebels want. Are we willing to concede them this victory?
Yes, the Red Corridor needs to be won back inch by inch.Yes, we need an iron hand sometimes. But the only road ahead is one by which tribals can finally get the security, development and good governance they deserve. Easier said than done, but that is the only way out, the ONLY way to address the grievances of the tribal populace. Individual states have to raise highly trained local anti-Naxalite commando force in the Greyhounds to tackle the Maoists, following it up with development (not just promises now, we need the REAL stuff, and quick) and an attractive surrender-and-rehabilitation scheme to wean off middle-level Naxalite cadre, a la Andhra Pradesh( the only state to have beaten the scourge so far).
Tribals make up a microscopic, if significant, minority of the population. Even the so-called “tribal states”, Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh, are only 26 per cent and 32 per cent tribal,respectively.So,the tribal colour is perpetually (and we realise now, conspicuously) absent in the Great Indian Political Rainbow.Tribals cannot look up to a Mayawati or a Mamata or a Karunanidhi for deliverance. This lack of political space creates a sense of emptiness that the Naxals, dressed up as Guevaras, so readily fill up. Grassroots-level inductment of tribal youth in local politics will succeed much more than a hundred armed commandos in furthering the counter-insurgency agenda.
Till then, we can best avoid parading corpses as trophies. In the war against the inhuman Maoists (who blew up the Jnaneshwari Express not so long ago), let our humanity prevail.

12 comments:

  1. nicely written dude. of course u don't need me (or anyone for that matter) to tell you that you got a good grasp of the language and have, at your disposal, enough tools to put into words, ur exact thoughts. but it is some of these thoughts that i don't agree with :

    1 - maoists are fuckin terrorists dude! and as such the harder we crack down upon them, the better for us.
    2 - spare a thought for our armed forces. they are called off their cantonments and homes to go and risk getting their heads blown off during a time of peace, and that too by their own countrymen. they are humans at the end of the day. and asking them to show humanity after days on end in the hot, humid, mosquito-infested jungles fighting an enemy they can't see while being bombarded with news of mutilated bodies of their friends being found, is a bit too much. maoists ain't got no humanity. they don't deserve it either.

    3 - as for the tribal problem, the indian state has, i believe, done a whole lot of stuff to bring them into the mainstream. the ones who remain downtrodden are so because they have either been very unlucky or they choose to continue with their lifestyles. and no matter what your grievances, nothing excuses aiding and abetting enemies of the state. they should not be won over, they should be defeated. i would say the easiest and best way to deal with the maoist menace is to burn the forest down (not literally). u wanna help them, u go down with them.

    ReplyDelete
  2. bottomline : we wud do ourselves a big favour by taking a cue from australia and the united states, those are the 2 nations who comprehensively dealt with their tribal problems.

    ReplyDelete
  3. 1.Mate,tribal development is not a game of COUNTERSTRIKE."Burning the forest down" is what we tried in the northest,but to no avail.Trigger-happy military intervention will only play into the Naxalites' hands...

    2.Those who join the armed forces are mentally prepared for the problems you describe( just like doctors are prepared to be called upon at the dead of the night or on Sundays).Hence,I daresay,your sympathy is GROSSLY misplaced.

    3.The state of Andhra Pradesh has WIPED OUT Naxalites---look how it was done!YS Rajasekhara Reddy never tried to outmuscle the Maoists.Killing the Maoists and not addressing the woes of the tribal populace would be criminal.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Don't blame the bullet and bless the gun.

    ReplyDelete
  5. What on earth are you talking about Devraj?

    In Australia and the USA,the voice of the tribals was RUTHLESSLY suppressed.Maoris and Red Indians have almost NO SAY WHATSOEVER in the government,you want India to replicate THAT?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

    ReplyDelete
  6. in the US, descendants of the red indians identify themselves fully with their country. same in australia. i say, we are in a state of undeclared war with an enemy whose sole intention is to bring this country down. they are giving us no quarters. i say we return the favor. i say let us bring them down. and all those who help them. in the war with the indian state, if your dear tribals are on the side of the enemy, they deserve no better treatment than the enemy itself. my only complain with the security forces is that they are too soft.
    we've done enuf of this velvet glove shit, time for the iron hand part.

    ReplyDelete
  7. P.S. - the maoris belong to new zealand, not australia

    ReplyDelete
  8. Andrew Symonds is from New Zealand,Eluru Reserve is in New Zealand,thanks for the information Devraj(tongue firmly in cheek)...

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. nycly written..but we have been saying that for lyk god knws hw many years...has it rilli made any difference?? Easier said dan done der hs been der hs been so many suggesstions by so many committee's formed by government has it made any difference?? d recent 1 t be the Rammohan Committee..d need of the hour is proper implementation of polcies wch we seriously are bad at!!

    @devraj
    1) harder we crack down upon them, the better for us
    u thnk so?? sorry dats nt happng we hav been dng dat with ur so calld fuckng terrorists has it rilli made any difference??we still hav 26/11 dont we !! only cz dey did sthng inhuman dsnt gv us d license to do the very same..why on earth den we hav sthng called as human rights???

    2) to show humanity after days on end in the hot, humid, mosquito-infested jungles fighting an enemy they can't see while being bombarded with news of mutilated bodies of their friends being found, is a bit too much...
    wat else are dey trained for sittng and sipping coffee or sthng?? dey r trained 2 hav der head ovr der shoulder watevr d sitution might be n dat can be no excuse at all..if we r takng for an eye for an eye den b ready for evrybody 2 be blind!!

    3) the indian state has, i believe, done a whole lot of stuff to bring them into the mainstream. the ones who remain downtrodden are so because they have either been very unlucky or they choose to continue with their lifestyles.....dat sch a unfair comment..so u "believe" lot of stuff hs bee done 2 bring dem 2 mainstream(dats an assumption or are u sure)i would really b intrested 2 knw wat exactly d government done apart frm noting down all policies on paper is dat what u say "a lot of stuff hs been done" dey choose 2 b unlucky or continue wid der lyfstyle?? dey are made unlucky and tell me whu would choose to go hungry for days 2gthr?? whu wld choose sch lyfstyle?? dats a total superficial comment..i hav been 2 maoists inflicted places n trust me dese ppl live in pathetic sitution..tell me wt do dey do wen der pleas go unheard for ages(not dat m spprtng d dantenwada, gyaneswari express viloence)
    ruthless killing is nvr d soultion..
    once agn nyc piece kip on cmng wid sch socially relevant piece cos sum ppl hav so wrng assumptions !!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Consider this by Arundhati Roy:
    "Right now in central India, the Maoists' guerrilla army is made up almost entirely of desperately poor tribal people living in conditions of such chronic hunger that it verges on famine of the kind we only associate with sub-Saharan Africa. They are people who, even after 60 years of India's so-called independence, have not had access to education, healthcare or legal redress. They are people who have been mercilessly exploited for decades, consistently cheated by small businessmen and moneylenders, the women raped as a matter of right by police and forest department personnel. Their journey back to a semblance of dignity is due in large part to the Maoist cadre who have lived and worked and fought by their side for decades."

    ReplyDelete